Shibboleth Developer's Meeting, 2021-12-03

Call Administrivia

09:00 Central US / 10:00 Eastern US / 15:00 UK / 17:00 FI

Calls are normally the 1st and 3rd Fridays of each month. Next call would be Friday 2021-12-17. Any reason to deviate from this?

60 to 90 minute call window.

This week's call will use the Zoom system at GU, see ZoomGU for access info.

Santuario / Jakarta move → looks like 2.1 may be sunsetting pretty quickly, trying to get confirmation on a date
OIDC / OAuth coordination
1. Inc. OP package name transfer to oidc-common for profile config. Which versions and when.
2. Features in the OP which requires the metadata resolver work in odic-common
(RDW) M2 verification is now on for IdP nightly build. Still outstanding (before we discuss other attacks)
1. Process for accepting new certs - we have such a case outstanding for net.minidev:json-smart:2.4.7
2. A plan for what to do if we do discover a forgery.

IDP-1870: Detect duplicate entityIDs when ingesting metadataClosed
- Coding done, just final live testing to do.
Will be out next meeting on Dec 17, so will need to use Scott’s Zoom, etc

JCOMOIDC-25: Bump Nimbus OIDC-SDK to 9.20Closed
- Related to the agenda item “Process for accepting new certs”
JCOMOIDC-28: Support for metadata policiesClosed
- JSON parsing via Jackson
- Should now be compliant with the OIDCfed draft, including unit tests
JOIDC-61: Support metadata policies in the dyn. reg. profile configurationClosed
- Some fine-tunings needed to the resolvers / caches, co-operating with Phil

JPAR-178: Update maven-javadoc-plugin to 3.3.0Closed updated this. Seems OK - at least for now.
Working on RP:
- Profile configuration hookup (OIDC.SSO for now)
- Message Encoders. Propose to borrow the ideas used in the SpringAwareMessageEncoderFactory but for OAuth ResponseModes and RP authn request. In JCOMOIDC-27: Add a spring aware message encoder factory for OIDC response modesOpen
Work on commons:
- Henri has ideas on how to improve the metadata resolver work, so I will revisit some of that.
- JCOMOIDC-21: Move net.shibboleth.idp.plugin.oidc.op.config from oidc-op-impl into commonsClosed - move some of the OP profile configuration stuff into oidc-common. Some is needed by the RP. Added timescales to the agenda on what gets released when and how the changeover in the OP happens.
- JCOMOIDC-26: Check JWT validation API is inline with the SAML validation APIOpen - need to check JWT validation API is suitable for upcoming use cases.
Other:
- Maybe look to switch the default CSRF validation predicate to use a constant-time algorithm. Although the predicate is injectable and I am not sure adds much in our case.

SP 3.3
- Would be nice to figure out if it’s “safe” to build these on an M1 Mac at some point.
- Package signing was an issue, ended up tunnelling GPG up to the server after uploading
  - Maybe look at doing the signing from within the Docker images somehow? Probably pretty hard to pull off.
- Already one minor bug in the deprecation logging, waiting for more bugs before I release a patch.
Started reviewing code for OAuth client_credentials grant and JWT token work
- General comment: there’s a ton of very complex machinery and token bloat built around the “avoid resolving some attributes on the backchannel” issue. We never even bothered to deal with this in SAML and it was never that big a concern that I’m aware of…was this a big enough concern to warrant all that effort and technical debt? Maybe moot I guess.